New to You: The Thrill of the Hunt!

Thrift and consignment stores galore throughout Orange County, New York

Bargain hunters, start your engines. Fabulous finds in furniture, household items, jewelry, artwork, and clothing will be new to you when you visit any of the thrift shops found throughout the county. Capture some “white elephants” and stretch you budget with super low prices and great stuff!

BULLVILLE
Changing Hands Thrift Shop/ Bullville Methodist Church Thrift Shop

2179 Route 17K, Bullville 10915
845-361-2721
Wed 9-1, Jan-Mar open only if weather is good

CHESTER
Back On The Rack

78 Brookside Ave, Suite #133, Chester 10918
845-774-2297, www.facebook.comMon-Sat 10-6
Children’s consignment, clothes, shoes, swings, and much more

CORNWALL
Encore Inc.

45 Quaker Ave, Suite 100, Cornwall 12518
845-458-8313, www.consign4acause.orgTues-Wed, Fri-Sat 10-5, Thur 10-7
A high end consignment shop.

FLORIDA
Random Acts of Consignment

42 North Main Street, Florida 10921
845-651-7012, https://www.facebook.com/RandomActsofConsignmentTues-Fri 10-6, Sat 10-4

GOSHEN
Red Door Thrift

36 John Street, Goshen 10924
845-294-5521
Mon-Tues, Thur, Sat 9:30-2, Fri 12-4

Twice Blessed Thrift Shoppe
Goshen Christian School
2430 Route 17A, Goshen 10924
845-294-8604, www.facebook.com/pages/Twice-Blessed-Thrift-Shoppe/227104670679412Sat 10-1

MAYBROOK
Diamond Jewels Upscale Resale

83 Homestead Avenue, Maybrook  12543
845-636-4755, 845-769-5239, www.diamondjewels518.com
Tues-Sun 10-6
Vintage/antique estate jewelry and clothing, accessories, wedding apparel, furniture, collectibles

MIDDLETOWN
Fort Knox Pawn Brokers
280 East Route 211, Middletown 10940
845-239-4047, www.fortknoxpawnbrokers.comMon, Thur 9-7, Tues-Wed, Fri-Sat 9-6, Sun 10-4
Electronics, clothing, shoes, musical instruments, some furniture

Guy’s and Gals Family Consignment Shop
285 Route 211 West, Middletown 10940
845-344-5894, www.facebook.com/pages/Guys-Gals-Family-consignment-shop/656253141145203Mon-Sat 10-5
Consignment

Lovely Ladies Consignment Shop
280 Route 211E, Suite 101, Middletown 10940
845-343-5277, www.facebook.com/lovelyladiesconsignmentshopMon-Sun 10-5
Consignment

Mama’s Best Deal
42 West Main Street, Middletown 10940
845-956-5700, www.facebook.com/MamasBestDealsTues-Fri 10-5, Sat 11-5

New 2 You – Quality Used Furniture
622 Route 17M, Middletown 10940
845-342-8733 www.Facebook.com/pages/New-2-You-Quality-Used-Furniture/494542817291284Wed-Fri 10:30-5, Sat 10-5, Sun 12-4

North Congregational Church
157 Linden Avenue, Middletown 10940
845-343-6688, www.northcongmiddletown.orgMon 6-8, Thur 10-2
Clothing, housewares.

Salvation Army
280 Route 211 East, Middletown 10940
845-343-1839, www.salvationarmy-usaeast.orgMon-Sat 9-8

Sweet Repeats
620 North St, Middletown
845-341-7433, www.facebook.com/sweetrepeats4uWed-Sat 11-5, Sun 12-4
Thrift shop with clothing and accessories for children, women and home. No consignments

United Presbyterian Thrift Shop
25 Orchard Street, Middletown 10940
845-343-2121, www.facebook.com/pages/United-Presbyterian-Thrift-Shop/525859150862984Tues-Wed, Fri 10-2

Your Treasure Shop
52 Dolson Avenue, Middletown 10940
845-343-8443, www.facebook.com/YourTreasureShopMon-Sat 10-6, Sun 12-3. In Summer closed on Sun.
Consignment.

MONROE
Cottage Thrift

Millpond Parkway, Monroe 10950
845-774-7273
Tues 6-8pm, Thurs, Sat 10-Noon

Our Mission of Grace Thrift Shop
Grace Episcopal Church, 1 Forest Avenue, Monroe 10950
845-782-8535
Sat 9:30-1
Clothing, Household, toys

MONTGOMERY
Cottage Thrift
110 Clinton Street, Montgomery  12549
845-401-9955, reannascloset@yahoo.com
Wed-Sat 11am-5:30pm, Sun 12-4pm

NEW WINDSOR
Bloomingdeals Resale (HVCPCA Thrift Shop)

436 Blooming Grove Tpke, Ste 500, New Windsor 12553
845-561-3180, www.bloomingdealsresale.comwww.facebook.com/BloomingdealsResaleMon 10-4, Tues-Sat 10-5
Thrift store and an adjoining furniture consignment store

Fort Knox Pawn Brokers
1012 Little Britain Rd, New Windsor 12553
845-567-6300, www.fortknoxpawnbrokers.comMon, Thur 9-7, Tues-Wed, Fri 9-6, Sat 9-5, Sun 10-4
Electronics, clothing, shoes, musical instruments, some furniture

NEWBURGH
Habitat ReStore
38 S. Plank Rd, Newburgh 12550
845-565-1789, www.habitatnewburgh.org/restorewww.facebook.com/HabitatNewburghWed-Sat 10-5
Mostly building materials, fairly large furniture section, appliances, lighting

Newburgh Vintage Emporium
5006 Route 9W, Newburgh 12550
845-562-5200, www.newburghvintageemporium.comwww.facebook.com/NewburghVintageEmporiumTues-Sun 10-6

PINE BUSH
Affordable Finds Family Consignment
65 Main Street, Pine Bush, NY 12566
(845) 421-7833, www.facebook.com/affordablefindsfamilyconsignmentMon-Tue, Thur-Sat, Sun 9-5, Closed Wed
Mens/womens/childrens clothing, accessories, formal wear/gowns, home décor/housewares, electronics, furniture

Classic Reruns
2412 Route 52, Pine Bush 12566
845-744-3976 www.classsicconsignmnet.comMon, Tues-Wed, Fri 11-6, Thur 11-7, Sat 11-5
Women’s and children’s clothing, home décor.

PINE ISLAND
The Hope Chest and Clothing Closet

20 Schoolhouse Road, Pine Island 10969
845-675-5009, www.clothingcloset.orgThur, Sat 10-1
Thrift shop featuring designer clothing, high-end toys, home goods, arts and crafts

Kiddie Exchange Consign
636 County Route, Pine Island 10969
845-258-2555, http://www.kiddieexchange.vpweb.comWed-Fri 10-5, Sat 10-4

PORT JERVIS
Gina’s Hope Chest

77 Fowler Street, Port Jervis 12771
845-856-4673, www.facebook.com/pages/Ginas-Hope-Chest/222841887754636Mon, Thur-Sat 9-3

Kiddie Klothes Line
37 Front Street, Port Jervis 12771
845-856-5896, www.kiddieklothesline.comwww.facebook.com/kiddieklotheslineTues-Sat 11-4

Salvation Army Thrift
130 Pike Street, Port Jervis 12771
845-856-1560
Mon 12-4, Tues-Sat 9:30-4

The Cottage House
132 Pike Street, Port Jervis 12771
845-856-9956, www.facebook.com/pages/The-Cottage-House/300398243495685Tues-Fri 11-3:30, Sat 11-4

SLATE HILL
Grace United Methodist Church Thrift

684 Ridgebury Road, Slate Hill 10973
845-355-2805
Tues-Wed 9-2

WARWICK
Amity Thrift Shop

110 Newport Bridge Road, Warwick 10990
845-986-6992
Sat 10-3

Christ Episcopal Church Thrift
50 South Street, Warwick 10990
845-986-3440
Sat 9:30-Noon

Encore Décor
24 Ronald Reagan Boulevard, Warwick 10990.
845-986-7001, www.shopencoredecor.comWed-Thurs 11-5, Fri 12-6, Sat 11-4, every other Sun 11-3
Furnishings, rugs, accessories, gifts, original artwork.

Reclaimed
11 West Street, Warwick 10990
845-544-7799, www.consignreclaimed.comTues-Wed, Fri-Sat 11am-6pm, Thur 11am-7pm, Sun 11am-5pm
Consignment-thrift, women’s clothing and accessories, designer

Savvy Chic Consign
26 Ronald Reagan Boulevard, Warwick 10990
845-988-2442, www.mysavvychicboutique.comMon-Fri 11-6, Sat 11-5

Too Sweet Kids Consignment Boutique, LLC
25 Elm St, Warwick, NY10990
845-544-1700 www.consigntoosweet.com www.facebook.com/pages/Too-Sweet-Kids-Consignment-Boutique-LLC/140647762629513Tues-Sat 9-4

WASHINGTONVILLE
Country Store Thrift Shop

12 Hallock Drive, Washingtonville 10992
845-496-8015, Facebook: Country-Store-Thrift-Shop
Tues, Fri-Sat 10-2

Translate »